"Seriously?" It may not be the most dignified of reactions, but Buffy can't help it any more than she can keep her jaw from dropping (just slightly) and her eyes from widening. Even in Sunnydale, it wasn't every day that she met someone else — someone not already a friend or ally, that is — who knew of the supernatural world. "Mine too. My boyfriend, I mean, he's a — was a vampire. And I was a telepath for all of two or three days before it nearly drove me crazy, which brings me to wow and all the way back to seriously? How did you deal with it? Can I ask that? Is that an okay thing to ask?"
no subject